top of page

The Answer That Wasn't Mine - By Himanshi

10 minutes ago
14 min read

Written By: Himanshi

Category: story

Competition: Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026

The Hashtag Kalakar Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026 brings to the fore "The Answer That Wasn't Mine," a captivating short story by Himanshi. This psychological mystery explores the depths of memory and the complexity of truth, set against the backdrop of a seemingly ordinary school life. Himanshi's narrative invites readers to embark on a journey of discovery, piecing together fragmented memories that challenge the protagonist's understanding of the past.

About the Work

Himanshi's work delves into the intricate dance between memory and reality. With a mood steeped in suspense and introspection, the story weaves a tapestry of questions and elusive answers. Rich with imagery of school corridors and rain-washed afternoons, it examines the protagonist's quest for truth amidst childhood promises and forgotten fears. The literary style is poignant, prompting readers to ponder the reliability of memory and the burdens it can carry.

The Answer That Wasn't Mine

Original Submission by Himanshi

THE ANSWER THAT WASN'T MINE

-A Psychological Mystery

The first answer arrived three days before anyone asked the question.

It was written on a small piece of paper, folded twice and slipped inside my schoolbag. The handwriting was neat, almost painfully familiar, though I couldn't remember ever seeing it before.

Question: What is the one thing you are most afraid of losing?

Answer: The truth about that Thursday.

I read it four times.

There were hundreds of Thursdays in my life. Ordinary Thursdays filled with unfinished homework, hurried breakfasts, and the familiar complaints of teachers. None deserved to be remembered, let alone feared.

Except, apparently, one.

I asked my closest friend whether she had put it there. She laughed and denied it. I wanted to laugh with her, but something stopped me. The paper smelled faintly of the lavender detergent my mother used on my school uniform.

That night, I searched every drawer in my room for something connected to a Thursday.

I found birthday cards, old report cards, photographs, and a notebook full of stories I'd written when I was younger. Between two yellowed pages lay a photograph of myself standing beside a girl whose face had been scratched out with a black pen.

On the back, in my own childhood handwriting, were five words:

We promised never to forget.

I didn't recognise the girl.

I didn't recognise the promise.

I carried the photograph downstairs.

“Mum, who is this?”

She was cutting vegetables when I showed it to her. Her knife stopped halfway through a carrot.

For a second, her expression changed into something I had never seen before-not surprise, exactly, but the look of someone who has heard a sound coming from a locked room.

Then she took the photograph from me.

“Where did you find this?”

“In my old notebook.”

She placed it face down on the counter.

“Some things are better left in the past.”

“Who is she?”

My mother looked at me, and I noticed that she was holding the knife so tightly her fingers had turned pale.

“I don't know,” she said.

It was the first lie I had ever caught her telling.

And somehow, I knew it wouldn't be the last.

---

The second note arrived the following morning.

This time, it was tucked inside my mathematics textbook.

Question: If someone remembers a lie for long enough, does it become the truth?

Answer: Only if everyone agrees to forget the truth.

I read the words while the classroom filled with the noise of chairs scraping against the floor and students exchanging homework. Outside, the sky was heavy with rain.

I turned the paper over.

Three words had been written in smaller letters at the bottom.

Room number seventeen.

Our school had no room seventeen.

I knew that because I'd spent six years there. The classrooms were numbered from one to sixteen, followed by the laboratory and the library. There was no seventeenth room on any floor.

Yet the words followed me throughout the day.

After school, I went to the old building behind the main school block. It had been closed for renovations for as long as I could remember. Dust covered the windows, and a rusted chain hung across the entrance.

I was about to leave when I noticed a small metal plate beside the door.

The paint had peeled away, revealing two faded digits.

17.

My heart began beating faster.

The chain was loose enough to move aside. I slipped through the entrance and found myself in a narrow corridor smelling of damp paper and old wood.

At the end stood a door.

Room 17.

Inside, there were broken desks, discarded charts, and a cupboard with a missing handle. Sunlight entered through a cracked window, illuminating the dust in the air.

On the teacher's desk lay a red notebook.

My name was written on its cover.

I opened it.

The first few pages contained children's handwriting, spelling mistakes, and little drawings of houses with impossible numbers of windows. The writing became neater as the pages progressed.

Then I found a list of questions.

What is your favourite colour?

Who is your best friend?

What do you remember about Thursday?

The first two questions had answers.

The third had been crossed out so thoroughly that the paper had almost torn.

Someone had written underneath it:

She remembers the rain. She must never remember the door.

I heard a sound behind me.

A footstep.

I turned so quickly that the notebook slipped from my hands.

Nobody was there.

But on the dusty floor, beside the doorway, lay a fresh white sheet of paper.

Question: What did you do when the door opened?

This time, there was no answer.

Only a date.

I recognised it immediately.

It was the date of the Thursday I had spent years trying to remember without knowing I had forgotten it.

---

That evening, I confronted my mother.

I placed the photograph, the two notes, and the red notebook on the dining table.

She stared at them for a long time.

“Tell me the truth,” I said.

She sat down slowly.

“When you were eight,” she began, “you had a friend named Mira.”

The name meant nothing to me.

“You were inseparable. She came to our house almost every day. You shared books, clothes, secrets. You even made up a language that nobody else could understand.”

“What happened to her?”

My mother looked towards the window.

“There was an accident at school.”

“What kind of accident?”

“It was raining. The old building had been closed, but you and Mira went inside. You were playing a game. You were supposed to be home before the rain became heavy.”

She stopped speaking.

“And?”

“There was a problem with one of the doors. It jammed. You managed to get out, but Mira didn't come home with you.”

I felt cold.

“Didn't come home?”

“We searched for her. The school searched. The police came. But she was never found.”

I shook my head.

“Then why don't I remember her?”

My mother reached across the table, but I pulled my hand away.

“After that day, you became very frightened. You stopped sleeping properly. You would wake up crying and ask for a girl named Mira. You said you had heard her calling you.”

“Did you take me to a doctor?”

“Yes. You were very young, and you had experienced something frightening. We followed professional advice to help you cope with the memories and the distress. Over time, the memories became less clear.”

“Less clear?” I repeated. “Or did you make me forget?”

She began to cry.

“I wanted you to have a life beyond that day.”

I looked at the photograph.

“You scratched her face out.”

“I didn't.”

The answer came too quickly.

For the first time, I believed her.

Someone else had done it.

Someone who had wanted Mira erased from our family photographs, our conversations, and eventually, my memory.

But who?

---

I returned to Room 17 the next morning.

The red notebook was still on the desk. I opened it to the final page and found a sentence I hadn't noticed before.

If she asks about the door, show her what she wrote.

Beneath it was a small envelope.

Inside lay a drawing made with a child's coloured pencils.

Two girls stood outside a wooden door. One wore yellow. The other wore blue. Above them, a cloud released thick lines of rain.

Under the drawing were the words:

Mira says I should go first because I know the way.

I stared at the page.

Something moved at the edge of my memory.

A narrow corridor.

A door that wouldn't open.

The sound of rain striking a window.

And a voice saying, “Don't leave me.”

I sat down.

The room seemed to tilt around me.

Another memory surfaced: two small hands pushing against wood, a frightened child calling for help, and the unmistakable sound of a second voice on the other side.

Then everything stopped.

I couldn't force the rest to come back.

For the first time, I understood that finding the truth would not necessarily make me feel better. It might make me feel worse. But I couldn't keep living inside a question somebody else had answered for me.

I turned the page.

A final note had been tucked into the binding.

You were not the only one who survived that Thursday.

I read it again. Then again.

Who else had survived?

My mother had said I was the only one who had come home.

The police had searched for Mira.

The school had closed the old building.

Nobody had ever mentioned another child.

Unless someone had.

I remembered a name written in the corner of the photograph.

Not Mira.

A name hidden beneath the black ink.

I took the photograph out of my bag and held it against the window. The light revealed the faint pressure of letters beneath the scratched surface.

A. SEN.

I knew that name.

Our school counsellor's name was Ananya Sen.

She had joined our school only a few months earlier, but she had a strange habit of watching me whenever the old building was mentioned. Once, when I had asked why Room 17 had been closed, she had changed the subject.

I had assumed she was simply strict about school rules.

Now I wondered whether she had been waiting for me to ask the right question.

---

I found her in the counselling room after lunch.

I placed the photograph on her desk.

The moment she saw it, her face lost its colour.

“Where did you get this?” she asked.

“Who is Mira?”

She didn't answer.

“Were you there that Thursday?”

Her hands folded together on the desk.

“Yes,” she whispered.

I waited.

“I was a trainee teacher at the school then. I was supervising the younger students that afternoon. Mira and you had gone into the old building without permission.”

“Did you find us?”

“We heard shouting. I reached the corridor, but the door had jammed. I called for help. By the time we got it open, you were outside, soaked and terrified.”

“And Mira?”

Ananya looked down.

“She wasn't in the room.”

“Then where was she?”

“I don't know.”

I stared at her, anger rising in my throat.

“You were there. You must know something.”

“I know that the official report never explained how you got outside. I know that you kept repeating the same sentence in the hospital: ‘I gave her the key.’ And I know that your family asked everyone to stop questioning you because every time somebody mentioned Mira, you became distressed.”

“The key?”

Ananya opened a drawer and removed a small plastic evidence bag.

Inside was a brass key, old and tarnished.

“This was found near the door. It belonged to the old classroom.”

I recognised it without knowing how.

My fingers began to tremble.

A memory returned-not the whole day, but one moment.

Mira was holding the key.

She was laughing.

I was telling her that we should leave.

Then came the argument.

I remembered wanting to prove that I wasn't afraid of the dark corridor. I remembered taking the key from her. I remembered running ahead.

And then I remembered the door closing.

I stepped backwards.

“No,” I whispered.

Ananya stood up.

“You were eight. Whatever happened, you were a child.”

“But I left her.”

“We never established that.”

“I had the key.”

“You were found outside. The key was found inside. That doesn't tell us everything.”

I wanted to believe her, but the memories were returning in fragments, and each fragment seemed to accuse me of something different.

“What happened to Mira?” I asked.

Ananya had no answer.

For years, I had imagined that the truth was a hidden object waiting to be found. Now I understood that it was a room full of broken pieces, and every piece cut differently.

I left the counselling room with the brass key in my pocket.

I didn't know why she had given it to me.

Perhaps she wanted me to stop asking questions.

Perhaps she wanted me to keep asking them.

---

That night, I opened the red notebook again.

I had brought it home without telling anyone.

At the back, behind the last page, was a folded sheet covered in handwriting that looked exactly like mine.

It was dated the day after the accident.

Dear Mira,

I am sorry I ran away. I thought you were behind me. I thought you would follow. When I heard you calling, I was scared, and I couldn't make myself go back.

I told them I didn't know where you were. I told them I couldn't remember.

I don't know if you will ever read this. I don't even know if you are still there.

But I remember your voice.

I am sorry.

There was no signature.

I sat on the floor until the room grew dark.

The letter didn't prove what had happened. It was the writing of a frightened child trying to make sense of something she couldn't understand. But it showed me that the memory had not vanished completely.

Some part of me had kept it.

Some part of me had been waiting.

I turned the page over.

At the bottom, almost hidden in the crease, was another line.

If I ever forget, let me find this letter.

For the first time, I wondered whether the notes had been left by someone who wanted to frighten me-or someone who had been trying to help me remember without forcing me to face everything at once.

The handwriting was familiar because it was mine.

The first note had been written on paper from my old notebook. The second had been tucked inside a textbook I had used for years. The red notebook had been hidden in a room I had known since childhood.

Someone had arranged the clues.

Someone who knew my habits.

Someone who could reach my belongings.

I searched my room again, this time looking not for memories, but for evidence.

Inside an old pencil box, I found a tiny voice recorder.

Its battery was dead, but the device still contained a memory card.

I borrowed a reader from my father and opened the files on my laptop.

Most were recordings of children's voices, old classroom conversations, and fragments of stories.

Then I found a file dated the Thursday of the accident.

I pressed play.

At first, there was only rain.

Then a child's voice.

Mine.

“Give it back, Mira.”

A second voice laughed.

“You said we were going together.”

“I changed my mind.”

“You promised.”

There was a scraping sound, followed by a loud bang.

Then silence.

And finally, a whisper.

“If you get out, tell them I went home.”

The recording ended.

I sat motionless.

It was the last sentence that changed everything.

Mira hadn't asked me to find help.

She hadn't asked me to remember.

She had asked me to lie.

Why?

---

The following morning, I returned to Room 17 with the recorder.

Ananya was already there.

She listened to the recording without interrupting.

When it ended, she closed her eyes.

“I should have told you,” she said.

“Told me what?”

“The search didn't end when the school closed the building. A week after the accident, someone found a message in the old caretaker's office. It was written by Mira.”

My breath caught.

“What did it say?”

Ananya took a folded document from her bag.

The handwriting was small and uneven.

I am not missing. I am afraid to go home.

I read it again.

Mira had been found that Thursday.

Not in the classroom, but in a narrow storage passage that connected the old building to the caretaker's office. She had been frightened, but alive. She had been taken away by relatives before the police could complete their interviews.

The school had known she was safe.

My mother had not.

And I had spent years believing that Mira had disappeared because I had left her behind.

“Why did nobody tell me?” I asked.

Ananya looked at me with an expression I couldn't read.

“Because the adults believed the truth would hurt you more than silence. Mira's family wanted privacy. Your family wanted you to recover. The school wanted the incident forgotten. Everyone had a reason.”

“And the notes?”

“I didn't write them.”

“Then who did?”

Ananya looked towards the door.

“I think you already know.”

I looked at the photograph again.

The name beneath the ink.

A. Sen.

It wasn't a signature.

It was a label from an old class register. Ananya had been assigned to supervise our class that year. The photograph had belonged to the school's lost-property collection before it was returned to my family.

She had helped me find the evidence.

But she hadn't written the notes.

I remembered the handwriting on the first slip.

The familiar loops.

The unusually long crossbar on the letter T.

I knew that handwriting.

It was mine.

---

I went home and spread the notes across my desk.

I placed the first message beside the childhood letter. I compared the shapes of the letters, the spacing, the way the ink pressed harder at the end of each sentence.

There was no doubt.

Every note had been written by me.

But I had no memory of writing them.

I checked the dates. The first note had been written in the back of my notebook. The second came from the pages of an old diary. The third was on paper taken from a school exercise book.

All of them were materials I had kept for years.

Then I remembered something small.

For the past month, I had been waking up early and finding my desk rearranged. I had blamed myself. I had assumed I was forgetting where I put things.

I opened the drawer beneath my desk.

Inside was another notebook.

On the first page, I had written:

If I begin to forget again, don't let me stop looking.

The pages that followed were filled with notes to myself.

Dates. Names. Questions.

A map of the old school building.

And one sentence repeated over and over:

Mira was alive. Mira was alive. Mira was alive.

I had been trying to solve the mystery before I consciously understood that there was a mystery to solve.

The answers weren't coming from a stranger.

They were coming from the part of me that had never stopped searching.

The revelation should have made everything simple.

Instead, it left me with a harder question.

If I had written the notes, why had I written them as questions and answers?

I turned to the last page.

There, in my own handwriting, was the final message.

Question: What are you most afraid of discovering?

Answer: That the person who remembers is not the person who lived it.

Below it, a final line had been added in blue ink.

You were a child. You are allowed to remember without punishing yourself forever.

I recognised the blue ink.

It was the pen Ananya had used in the counselling room.

She must have read the notebook before returning it to me.

For the first time, I understood the difference between remembering and accusing myself.

I had spent years treating my childhood self as a criminal who had escaped punishment. But the truth was more complicated. I had been frightened. I had been confused. I had made choices I could not fully understand at eight years old.

And I had carried the blame long after the adults had stopped asking questions.

The notes had not been a supernatural warning.

They had been a trail I had left for myself.

Not because I knew every answer, but because some part of me understood that I would eventually be ready to ask the questions.

---

I wrote a letter to Mira.

I didn't ask her to forgive me. I didn't ask her to explain the past. I simply told her what I remembered, what I didn't, and what I had discovered.

I sent it through the contact details Ananya provided, without expecting a reply.

For three days, nothing happened.

On the fourth day, an envelope arrived.

Inside was a recent photograph of two women standing beside a lake. One of them was a stranger to me. The other had the same smile as the girl in the yellow dress.

On the back, someone had written:

I remember the rain, too.

There was no signature.

I sat at my desk and held the photograph until the afternoon light faded.

I had spent so long searching for a perfect explanation that I had forgotten something important: not every mystery ends with every question answered. Sometimes, the truth arrives only far enough to let you take the next step.

I opened my notebook and wrote one final question.

What happens when the truth finally returns?

For a long time, I didn't write an answer.

Then I understood that I didn't need one.

I closed the notebook, placed the photograph inside it, and turned off the light.

For the first time in years, I wasn't afraid of Thursday…..!

About the Competition

The Hashtag Kalakar Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026 is a celebration of literary talent and creativity. This prestigious event invites writers from across the globe to showcase their unique voices through poetry, short stories, and creative writing. It serves as a platform for emerging and established authors alike to share their narratives with a wider audience, fostering a vibrant community of literary enthusiasts.

We extend our gratitude to Himanshi for sharing "The Answer That Wasn't Mine" with us as part of the Hashtag Kalakar Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026. Your contribution enriches the tapestry of stories that explore the human condition, and we eagerly anticipate the impact it will have on readers seeking to unravel the mysteries of memory and truth.

About Hashtag Kalakar

Hashtag Kalakar is a creative platform dedicated to providing artists, writers, singers and other creative talents with opportunities to showcase their work and reach wider audiences through competitions, features and creative initiatives.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Maroon - By Aditya Mallya

Written By: Aditya Mallya Category: Short Story Competition: Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026 In the compelling short story "Maroon," Aditya Mallya, writing under the name Maroon, present

 
 
 
Bilateral Symmetry - By Aditya Mallya

Written By: Aditya Mallya Category: Screenplay Competition: Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026 Aditya Mallya presents "Bilateral Symmetry," a screenplay featured in the Creative Writing cat

 
 
 
Midnight Street - By Aditya Mallya

Written By: Aditya Mallya Category: Poetry Competition: Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026 Aditya Mallya, writing under the name "Midnight Street," offers a captivating piece in the Poetry

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page