On Justice - By Arnav Nirajkumar Thool
Written By: Arnav Nirajkumar Thool
Category: Creative Essay
Competition: Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026
Arnav Nirajkumar Thool presents a profound exploration of justice and morality in his creative essay, "On Justice." Featured in Hashtag Kalakar's Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026, this piece invites readers into a world of philosophical inquiry and historical reflection. Through a dialogue that traverses time and the realms of human conscience, Thool challenges us to consider the complexities of justice in a world marked by both triumph and tragedy.
About the Work
"On Justice" is a thought-provoking essay that delves into the themes of historical justice and moral philosophy. Arnav Nirajkumar Thool uses vivid imagery and a narrative style reminiscent of Dante's journey to confront historical figures like Hitler, questioning the nature of guilt and justice. The piece is infused with a reflective tone, prompting readers to ponder the moral compass of humanity and the weight of historical legacies.
On Justice
Original Submission by Arnav Nirajkumar Thool
“The greatest happiness is to scatter your enemy and drive him before you. To see his cities reduced to ashes. To see those who love him shrouded in tears.” Do you know who said this?
The man before me smiled at the thought of Genghis Khan and immediately began to voice his own opinions. His talk was all about the growth and prosperity of his own nation. He recollected how he manipulated people of his nation to pledge their lives for their country.
His strong voice appealed to them while his ambition gave the idle a cause.
But he was no less than the Sirens.
Today the world remembers. The World Wars… Hiroshima… The Holocaust.
That man wreaked havoc.
But did he get what he deserved?
*
‘I am the Shade, let me guide you,
Let me reveal what is true.
Through this journey you shall see,
The work of God and Justice eerie.
Ashes, ashes, gore and death
Will escort your every breath
If you wish to see the day
Leash your mind, lest it goes astray.
*
‘Over the pile of bones, besides the Hemlock tree
Lies the body of a demon- can you see?’ so asked my guide.
‘Most certainly sir,’ said I
The Shade continued thus- ‘That man upon whom you gaze, was more dangerous than Greek Fire. His mind, sharper than the scythe of Kronos. He was- do you wish to see him?’
‘Nothing would suffice’ replied I.
As we drew closer and closer to that man, the air grew colder, the colour seemed to slowly fade away, as though life itself was afraid to approach this man.
And when I finally saw him, I could see why.
In his eyes, there was no life- only the memory of it. In that frail skull, I could feel something dark lurking inside. Those ghosts came back. The camps… The slavery… the years of hiding… those curling shrieks… I shut my eyes to erase the memories, and with trembling hands I spoke to the man.
‘Are you really… I mean are you…’ My voice fell short and in a barely audible whisper I uttered the name.
‘Are you… Hitler?’
The reply sent chills, his heavy voice said, ‘I am, and who are you to wander in this place? You are not dead-’ his eyes slid over to the Shade, ‘ah… I see, guiding another one are you. Like you did aeons ago. What was his name… Dante wasn’t it?’
My guide said nothing, his face was decorated with the expression of a corpse.
‘Well, no matter. Come here boy’ he beckoned me to come closer, and I obeyed. Told you these men were Sirens. ‘Well, boy you do know me, so there’s little to tell you. Welcome to Hell and if you are wondering what misdeed I did… well I think you know that too, don’t you?’
‘I know. You are no less than the devil, and you still have no guilt over it do you?’ I asked him.
‘What is guilt, my boy? To be sad and remorseful for things done for a cause? No… guilt is man’s way to shame another’s conscience. You say this conscience only lies with the sane ones, do you? But let me tell you, those who are mad… well, they are juggernauts, aren’t they?’
I considered the thought for a minute. He was right in a way. Mad ones don’t feel the sense of right or wrong... The one who does not know law cannot know crime. Didn’t G.B. Shaw say that the world needs a few mad men, the sane ones have landed us in trouble…
I was about to commit to agreement with the dictator, but then the Shade reminded me
‘Leash your heart, and hold it tight
For the tyrant’s mind, though sharp and bright,
Houses shadows out of sight.
Hold to truth, do not betray-
Lest your reason loses its way’
I found some scraps of courage with the Shade’s words and I asked him ‘“The greatest happiness is to scatter your enemy and drive him before you. To see his cities reduced to ashes. To see those who love him shrouded in tears.” Do you know who said this?’
Hitler smiled at the words of Genghis Khan and immediately began to voice his own opinions. He said ‘Genghis Khan, isn’t it? I know’
‘Then did you find peace and pleasure in all the bloodbaths you had? Tell me, did you enjoy stitching lamp-sheets out the Jews’ faces? Did you enjoy killing men in those gas chambers? Was it pleasing to watch people slaughtered like goats in your “Final Solution”?! Tell me did you find it entertaining to commit to genocide! Tell me!’
He simply said ‘If can send a flower of the German nation into the hell of war without the smallest pity for shedding the precious German blood then surely, I have the right to remove millions of inferior races that breed like vermin. The holocaust was the simplest and the most humane solution for the question of lower races.’
‘By killing millions of innocents?!’
I froze and I think Hitler did too. It was the first time I heard the Shade speak with emotion, it looked as he had catharised. But the Shade wasn’t done yet.
‘You have no idea, what lies in store for you.’, erupted my guide, ‘Do you know the more time you spend in hell the more you suffer. Conceited German! You are only in the shallowest part of hell, if you think this is the last stage, reconsider… You have not even seen the deepest circles where even light and colour dare not enter! Look in the horizon! Look I say, can you see him? The tiny blob peeking out of that crimson river? That is the skull of the one your soul recognizes! There lies Genghis Khan submerged at the bottom of that river of blood! And you-’
‘Oh, shut up.’ said Hitler, ‘I shall see what happens, go away shoo! Leave me alone.’
Hitler overstepped. My guide took on a demonic shape and tore Hitler apart like a rag doll, until it seemed as if there had been no human there. The Shade hungrily ate up all the remaining pieces and drank the crimson liquid, as though this was a normal thing.
‘Oh, don’t worry. He will arise as the sun sets today. You see, It’s a part of his punishment.’ Explained my humble guide with a gruesome smile stained with the blood of Hitler.
*
And so, we ascended from the Devil’s abode and made our way to mine. Upon reaching the surface, The Shade spoke:
‘In these woods you may rest,
Until the Heavens are ready for their guest.
Do not fear I shall be back,
Before morrow’s dawn will crack.’ Saying so he disappeared in a cloud of grey mist.’
Now being alone in the dark, creepy forest where I started my journey, I wandered around in the quest of a stump to rest upon. Having found a crooked, stooped tree. (Possibly a dead willow tree), I sat down in its branches and once comfortable thought about the events of the day.
Indeed, the day had been tiring, yet it was renewing its spirit with each passing event of my journey. I met The Shade, entered the Devil’s domain, descended hundreds of miles beneath the Earth and the climax… I met Hitler. I met the man (at least his soul) whom I developed a feeling that the wizards developed for Voldemort.
I still wonder how a man can develop hatred for another group and amplify it to such a scale that resulted in mass extinction. Is there no force that controls this universe? Was God Almighty sleeping when Hitler snatched away sleep from men? I mean, there should be something that oversees our actions, right? Otherwise, the 7 billion people believing that justice always prevails are just misguided.
A man is guided by an inner compass of right and wrong, but what if that compass is already broken? Then Hitler is born. Many people believe in a moral universe, directly or indirectly. If you believe that a superpower called God sits over the Universe and rewards right with Heaven and punishes wrong, on top of that He avenges the shadowed victim of Fate’s injustice, then you believe that a moral universe exists. Didn’t Dostoevsky say “If God does not exist, then all things are permitted.” Nietzsche’s declaration that “God is dead” was not atheism, but the recognition that humanity’s compass is broken.
But is there justice in history, does the moral universe give justice to the victims of injustice? Did Hitler receive his part of punishment for his crimes? If you say that he lost the war or the Holocaust led to the foundation of Universal Human Rights, then did the lives of those 6 million Jews, and the 7 million innocents count for nothing? Did they receive justice for their unjust killing after those Human Rights were rewarded to their corpses?
Forget about Hitler. Let’s talk about the person who himself used it encourage people to commit to a cause, ‘The arc of moral universe is long, but it bends towards justice.’ Do you know him? Martin Luther King Jr.
King fought, he strove for racial equality, civil rights, social justice. I cannot deny that he succeeded. But in the end, he was assassinated, then did his work count for nothing? Where was the moral universe then? The idea of moral universe implies the idea of Immanent Justice; it implies that our moral actions decide our outcome. The greater the deed, the better the reward. King’s deeds were the best works ever done by a man. His selfless actions defined the course of America’s future.
The Bus Boycotts, the Selma to Montgomery Marches, the Poor People’s Campaign and the Civil Right Acts … all these demonstrations, protests and marches pressured the American Congress to end racial discrimination, segregation of races in public areas, think about poor people, civil rights and basic responsibility towards people.
Yet King was martyred. Killed for serving humanity, killed for serving his people, killed for serving the right cause. Where was the immanent justice? Where was the reward?
Some may argue that justice does not lie in the fate of individuals, but in the legacy, they leave behind. Some may say that through the laws King acquired for his people may be justice enough for his death, then justice becomes eventual, not immediate. King himself said so. But then, if justice cannot protect the just and exposes itself long after the victims are dead, then what remains of it but a consolation?
If justice is only the dignity of victims and the exposure of cruelty, then why do their names fade while the oppressors remain etched in history? We remember Hitler, but not the millions he destroyed. We recall the tyrants, yet the voices of the gas chambers and the cries of the enslaved dissolve into the national anthems, folk songs that the people sing proudly. We remember the separation on colour in our country, but not those who were separated. History favours those who stand out in power, not those crushed beneath it.
I felt a hand rest on my shoulder and my guide spoke with the weight of an adage, and his words carried centuries of serving justice to people. He simply said:
‘The arc of the moral universe is said to be long,
But to call it an arc may still be wrong.
For when it stretches, thin and straight,
It stops its bend and becomes a line of fate.’
***
About the Competition
The Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026 by Hashtag Kalakar celebrates the art of expression through words. It provides a platform for writers to showcase their unique voices and perspectives. The competition is open to diverse categories, encouraging creativity and critical thinking among participants, fostering a vibrant community of literary talent.
Thank you, Arnav Nirajkumar Thool, for your compelling contribution, "On Justice," to the Poetry and Creative Writing Competition 2026. Your essay offers a profound exploration of themes that resonate deeply, provoking thought and reflection. We are grateful for your participation and the insight your work brings to our community.
About Hashtag Kalakar
Hashtag Kalakar is a creative platform dedicated to providing artists, writers, singers and other creative talents with opportunities to showcase their work and reach wider audiences through competitions, features and creative initiatives.


Comments